Increasing Legal Fees Aren’t Reflected in Costs Awards in Small Claims Court

The Rules of the Small Claims Court (the “Rules”) allow Deputy Judges to use their discretion when awarding costs to a successful party, subject to limitations under Section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act (the “CJA”).

Rule 19.01(1) of the Rules allows a successful party to have their reasonable disbursements, which include amounts paid for effecting service, costs of preparing a Plaintiff’s or Defendant’s Claim or a Defence, expenses for travel, accommodation, photocopies and Experts’ Reports, to be paid by the losing party.

For many years, Rule 19.01(4) awarded a successful party $100.00 for preparation of pleadings, which was recently changed to $200.00.  It’s a start, but it’s not enough.

Despite Rule 19.01(1), which claims a successful party is entitled to amounts paid for effecting service, Rule 19.01(3) basically limits that to a whopping $60.00.  I think Process Servers were charging this when I graduated a long time ago.

Despite requesting what our clients actually pay for Process Server fees, there is usually a fair bit of pushback from Deputy Judges who only rely upon Rule 19.01(3), despite invoices can be as high as $300.00!

Another issue on costs is at Assessment Hearings, where Deputy Judges do not want to award 15% of the amount claimed for representation, despite being permitted by the Rules.

Rule 19.04 provides that the Court may award a party (who is represented) a reasonable representation fee at Trial or at an Assessment Hearing.  That amount cannot exceed 15% of the amount claimed pursuant to Section 29 of the CJA.

Deputy Judges tend to take the position that 15% applies to Trials only, despite the rule listing both Trials and Assessment Hearings, which is by definition “an undefended Trial.”

Additionally, most of our clients have a term in their Contracts that states they are entitled to all their legal fees upon default.  This still doesn’t always sway some Deputy Judges into awarding what the Rules permit at an Assessment Hearing.

The purpose of suing someone is to be put in the position they were in before the default.  This should include payment of legal fees.

Costs to litigate continue to increase, and it’s time that the Small Claims Court acknowledges this and starts reflecting it in cost awards to make successful parties whole, or as close to whole as possible.

Murray Brown, Licensed Paralegal

Share via
Copy link